Analysis: GGP Declares Chapter 11

Well, the loss of my lunchtime bolt hole has proved a bit of a problem for me in finding time to post in the last couple of weeks. To be fair, I have been working on (and completed) a draft of the business plan, and have also selected a group of vendors to approach in the coming weeks for a build estimate.

Meantime my next major task is completing a functional spec for the site, as there's no way I trust the average coding monkey with the all-important design and usability. Overall it is going very well, and I am feeling really positive that I can create something unique, useful and commercially viable.

Of course the big news of the last fortnight was GGP finally filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.

The final straw was the combination of the bond solicitation process failing to persuade sufficient Rouse bondholders to extend, and the threat of action from disgruntled creditors ready to file a claim on certain malls - that meant GGP had little choice but to seek to protect its assets from being effectively raided.

GGP filed with $27.3 bln debt and $29.6 bln assets - figures that are of course disputed - and obtained $375 million in debtor-in-possession financing courtesy of Pershing Square.

Bill Ackman is a canny operator, and clearly used this to hedge Pershing's existing position (at 25% they are the third largest shareholder in GGP currently). By providing DIP financing, Pershing yields a healthy 12% annual return on the debt. Additionally Pershing gain warrants to buy 4.9% of the new equity when it emerges from bankruptcy, and most interestingly the potential to convert the $375m DIP into equity.

The latter option has to be admired, as it ensures Pershing Square will be guaranteed equity whichever way the firm emerges from bankruptcy. I am confident however that it remains strongly in Ackman's interests to maintain common shareholder value, although this does now raise the spectre of dilution. I have analysed this in some detail, and believe that dilution risk is a minimal factor: if the event occurs, that means GGP will have successfully restructured, emerged from bankruptcy and the huge upside potential to the shares will offset and limit any impact.

GGP President, Tom Nolan, gave several interviews subsequently, and placed the blame squarely on the frozen credit markets as the primary cause of GGP's current problems. It will clearly form the central crux when outlining the company's argument as to why a loan extension agreement is justified, and increases the likelihood of approval by the courts.

Certainly the fact that no major rivals who wanted to buy some of the best, revenue-generating properties put up for sale could secure funding is a powerful illustration of the wider market problems, and in favour of GGP.

Nolan also stated that GGP does not see an immediate need to tap DIP financing for 8 weeks, due to cash flow business running costs illustrates the relatively healthy position of the business model. Once again, GGP stands out as an unusual case. Bill Ackman also immediately went to the press to rubbish assumptions by many that GGP's weakness would be to the gain of rivals, by effectively meaning Chapter 11 meant liquidation and an eventual firesale of assets.

Today Fitch downgraded some of GGP's CMBS debt, citing that:

"If the properties remain in bankruptcy, General Growth could seek to load up the properties with additional debt to help repay their corporate unsecured debt."

So far, everything has progressed exactly as I had hoped with regards to the Chapter 11 filing, with the exception of Pershing's DIP equity conversion option. Liquidation and/or widescale share dilution remain the only scenarios in which being long in GGP would not produce significant returns.

It will be interesting finding out what the restructuring proposal submitted to the court contains.  The above illustrates another mechanism by which GGP could pay off unsecured lenders and/or the bondholders without necessarily needing to sell properties.  A key point mentioned here but not considered is that GGP are completing a strategic review, with a specific aim of only offering to liquidate lesser malls as part of the court proposal.

A combination of financial re-engineering, some limited asset sales, and a wider extension request for loans until the credit markets recover sufficiently to enable normal refinancing is the most likely right now.