Cyclical Investing - Prost!

Firstly a quick word on my pre-wedding Stag weekend at Oktoberfest: excessive.. Bavarian.. fantastic! I was fortunate to go with a large group of bankers from the City (mostly Australian), who made the whole experience far better as many had been before. As such we had a great hotel just minutes from the festival, and they ensured we weren't one of the throngs without a table on the opening day.

It's a wonderful affair that despite attracting too many tourists, due to the numbers of Germans who also attend it manages to retain its cultural identify. I thought the sheer number of locals who turned up wearing traditional costume was magnificent: there is just no way we Brits would be able to take ourselves seriously wearing leather shorts.

From the singing (I challenge anybody not to have learned the lyrics to Ein Prosit by the time they leave) to the continuous shouts of 'Prost!' (cheers/bottoms up) - it was all about fun.

Oh, and for some reason I really liked the traditional Bavarian costume for the girls... I can't work out why but I'm dreaming about L wearing it now...



Champagne Tarts
On the subject of drinks, I had a few with some more senior bankers last week that was an interesting look at changing behaviour as they get older. Being mostly in their 40's and 50's they chose an old school City bar that I had never even heard of - apparently it has been around for 30 years or more, so I was informed by one fossil.

I arrived late (I still work for a living) to discover them all sprawled around several tables, reminiscing over the days when everything was charged to expenses, the Lehman Brothers collapse and generally what a complete fuck up the last year has been.

What caught my eye immediately was the lack of champagne or wine. I discounted them all vying for the first male pregnancy despite several looking due. It seems that the banker equivalent of contributing to the new Age of Austerity was everybody drinking bottled Guinness of all things. Presumably this is the 'new Champagne' in these cash strapped times - you heard it here first people, and when Diageo's shares soar on the news you know who to thank.

Still it did remind me how the days of 2005 are long gone, when amongst other bankers I had occasionally got through champers on a night out without a second thought. The bar in question was called Harry's near Cannon Street, and must hold the title of Seediest Bar In The City. On appearances, it's quite a nice little underground cellar conversion which serves good everything.

However by the time I left at 10pm the place was awash with a sea of tarted up slappers, who all clearly had arrived to play 'bed a banker'. You get the equivalent with teenage Essex girls for bankers in their 20's, so I suppose this is what they look like 20yrs on.

I watched various aforementioned tarts wander in, add another layer of foundation to cover themselves before boldy striking up conversations with the various fat bankers in their 40's and 50's dotted around the bar. What struck me were the number of single men drinking alone, and I noticed these women seemed to almost be cycling between them until they got a hit. Presumably that's my future if I stay in banking for another 20yrs - put on 40lbs and start frequenting seedy bars for illicit affairs. Yuck, what a thought.

So Many Opportunities
My thoughts are now increasingly turning to where the next big opportunity will lie after GGP as an investment. The biggest mistake many amateur investors make is to make a decision for the sake of it. Reading back I notice making that same point as I sat on significant losses on the General Growth trade back in February and March this year.

It usually takes getting burned through a couple of rash decisions before you start to realise that one of the most intelligent things you can often (but not always) do when not sure is to do nothing at all.

Buffet himself is a master at sitting on his hands when no opportunities are apparent. Berkshire Hathaway hoarded cash during the boom years, with many questioning the value of this for investors - but note how much he has been busy spending in the last 18 months by contrast. So the same of course should apply for the smaller investor, and right now the markets are like taking a walk through an orchard with trees laden with fruit. The big question however, is which will be the first to ripen, and hence which to hold as opposed to watch?

This commentary from 10 months ago is interesting, because from this you can look back and compare its accuracy:

"Even in depressed markets, it is typical for the market to stage significant bear market rallies, as witnessed in the 1930s and in Japan during the 1990s. Perhaps the best example was seen in the aftermath of the 1929 stock market crash, in which the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) rallied close to 50% from its November low to an April peak. Comparing the present day S&P/TSX with the DJIA circa 1929-1930, it is interesting to note very similar price patterns, plus seasonality which would suggest that the stock market could stage a bear market rally through the year end, as is typical at this time of year. " First Trust Quantitative Research - Dec 2008 Monthly Commentary

Not a bad observation to have made back in December 2008 I would say. So the post-1929 crash then saw a 5 month rally with a near 50% increase. Since March we have seen close to a 6 months rally now with an approximate 50% increase, but what about the future? What the commentary does not go into detail on is then pointing out that after this peak, the Dow Jones dropped back again (hence why it is referred to as a 'bear rally').

Investment Cycle
At a high level it is always useful to look at this old illustration of the investment cycle produced by Merrill Lynch Investment Management years ago:

Although it simplifies hugely, what this does also do is give a good sense of the need to make sure money flows regularly into different areas and sectors of the economy throughout the cycle to maximise returns. Before anybody objects or points out the danger of constantly investing/reinvesting, note I am referring to the economic cycle - which typically follows a 10-15yr cycle between peaks of each boom, so you can allow (very approximately) 2-4yrs per quarter depending upon severity.

This time, the cycle was skewed quite spectacularly after the dot com boom and crash by the flood of cheap credit, which effectively fast tracked back into a second boom. However that was exceptional, and in future it is reasonable to assume we will revert to the more standard cycle.

So firstly let's look at where we are right now - clearly in the red of recession. Looking back a year ago, you would have expected defensive sectors such as healthcare, consumer staples and utilities were the best places to put money. That would not be too far off, although the extraordinary nature of the credit crisis meant that financials have undergone an early return to favour - at least for now - with some amazing returns in the last 9 months. I would argue that this has gone beyond fair at this stage in the cycle.

In these times, this illustrates that investors should have been focusing their search for the best opportunities in the last 6 months on growth stocks above all else. I have a long term hold in the South American company Mercardo Libre for example, which has been posting very high growth levels right through the recession, and yet took a major hit on its share price during the October 2008 crash despite no rational justification.

Sure enough, its growth has continued, and has seen a 94% rise in stock price over the last 6 months, which illustrates the returns out there. In my case, I bought into MELI long ago but looking back I bought in at the wrong time in the cycle - hence why I moved into a loss through the downturn, and am only up a modest 30% after several years. A useful illustration of the power of timing however.

My view is that small caps should remain the focus for now, although investors should be increasingly eyeing up the early cycle sectors, which include consumer discretionary (financials already covered). The late cycle sectors include materials, energy, industrials and technology, and defensive include consumer staples, healthcare, utilities by the way. There is plenty of time for further analysis and I will be drawing up a candidate list to complete detailed analysis soon - just that small matter of a wedding looming on the horizon...