Brave New World

I do feel I ought to apologise for my tardiness in posting since I returned from California, although as I mentioned in a reply to the reader who was kind enough to take the time to ask if I was still alive, I have come across a fairly obvious downside to studying for CFA whilst working full time at the bank (and looking around for a new role) - namely I never seem to have any spare time anymore.

On that note, I have made good on my promise and have made the big jump out of investment banking! No, no, no.. I have not 'seen the light' and decided to shave my head in readiness for a life of selfless devotion to others. Instead I have sold my soul to the devil with a sideways move into private banking - which is also a useful move further towards asset management.

I cannot say that I felt much regret as I sprung the news of my resignation on the Boss, just days after my bonus reached the safety of my account. He looked surprised initially - as if I had smacked him in the face, but then quickly a look of familiarity overcame him, it is not like he has not seen it all before. As I mentioned in my last entry way back in November, despite being amongst the world's most prestigious banks, my former employers have seen an exodus in recent months.

The irony is that having turned down a role for £50,000 more per annum back in March last year, I ended up snaring almost twice that with this move. Bonuses seem to have gone out of fashion, and it's all about the base.

Anyway going back to the lack of time, I wonder if that is why 99% of blogs do dry up after a year or two. Actually I suspect it is more running out of things to discuss. Of course, I've always got more than enough opinions to foist upon the unwilling world, but thought that I would devote this entry to a review of a fascinating couple of months for General Growth Properties, some comparative analysis into its current valuation, and a quick look at the recent report into the unwinding of the TARP programme and its impact upon the markets in 2010.

GGP - Into Double Digits (Briefly)
With the share price catapulting up by another 100% at its peak since my previous mail back in late November, it is worth reflecting on the underlying reasons. After all, continual reassessment is critical for the effective management of any portfolio.

Is the market being rational to value a company in bankruptcy at over $3 billion?

Key to the rises was the positive news regarding loan refinancing negotiations with secured creditors. That included the November 19 release that GGP had secured agreements in principle, followed by the filing of a Plan of Reorganization for some $9.7 billion of secured mortgage loans.

Adam Metz ensured that the propaganda machine was running at full capacity, with misrepresentative lines about GGP exiting Chapter 11 protection by the year end grabbing the headlines. It was always an unrealistic time frame, not to mention only a partial restructuring with a great deal of the important work still to do.

Having said that, a major part of General Growth Properties problems were a loss of confidence, and so instilling that in the markets once again is important - not least in the continuing creditor negotiations. By the time that aspect of the refinancing was approved by the court in mid-December, investors were partying, with myself no exception as my unrealised profits on the trade topped £1 million for the first time.

So it was with some amusement that I read through Hovde Capital's publication of a thesis that GGP shares were in fact horribly overvalued and that common stock would soon be worthless. The fact that the fund was short GGP, and the word on the street is that they are still sitting on some major losses, made it an enormous comedy. Obviously I bought into the plummet in the share price the day after it was published - but the damage to less sophisticated investors through such cynical market manipulation makes this more serious.

To say that Hovde's flawed analysis pissed off long investors more familiar than most with valuing the company might be an understatement. It is certainly rare to see two hedge funds like Pershing Square and Hovde Capital slugging it out in a war of presentations over the next fortnight, with other noteable commentators such as Whitney Tilson adding their voices to those denouncing Hovde's analysis for its fundamental flaws.

There is no point me summarising that whole saga now, as it was reported in so much detail elsewhere. This Marketfolly page is useful for giving the whole timeline and debate that raged during this period.

Ultimately though the markets are the real judge of these things, and while down from recent peaks, General Growth quickly recovered up to around $11/share. It has since of course fallen back to lows under $9/share, although remains firmly on the upward trend since filing for Chapter 11. I expect 52 week highs to be tested as additional court proceedings progress, and further unsecured creditors agree to the mass 5 year extension template that has been proposed.

GGP Valuation
As a mark of how long it has taken me to get around to completing this entry, I finished this comparative analysis of GGP versus its peer group several weeks ago, based upon an extract of sector FFO estimates using data from 21 Jan 2010.

As you can see, the all important price / FFO multiple estimates for General Growth Properties when its share price was $1.50 more than current are still the lowest in the entire sector. That is one of the key indicators of value, quid pro quo. Of course there are a multitude of other factors to take into account, but without going back over old ground and remaining on pure, technical analysis I am confident that General Growth remains the best hold in the sector at this time.

Unwinding TARP - Challenges & TALF
A key factor that will impact the markets in 2010 and beyond is the withdrawal of the quantitative easing policies that have buoyed the markets. I recommend taking a look at this report by the Congressional Oversight Panel as the section on TALF (page 106) conclusion is interesting - in summary that unwinding will have a minimal impact upon the commercial real estate market, and should provide comparatively few issues.

That's all for now campers, I'll do my best to get another entry together soon. Meantime I will be busy in Knightsbridge with my new colleagues, around the international travel that will apparently be making up a significant part of my role going forwards.